HOV Facilities and Use

 

Northern Virginia boasts one of the country's most successful high occupancy vehicle (HOV) systems. More than 44,000 travelers choose to use one of Northern Virginia’s three HOV freeway corridors[6] for their morning commutes.  HOV lanes have become an integral part of the Washington Metropolitan region’s transit system. The program restricts certain highway lanes to exclusive use by multi-occupant vehicles at peak travel times to encourage carpooling, vanpooling and transit bus ridership. 

The bus-only lanes that opened on the Shirley Highway in 1969 were the first HOV lanes in the country.[7]  NVTC managed a major demonstration of express buses in this corridor. These lanes were then opened up to high occupancy private automobiles to promote more efficient fuel use in 1973. Construction of HOV lanes throughout the country progressed slowly in the 1970s and then began to pick-up in the mid-1980s to early 1990s. 

 High-occupancy vehicle facilities are designed to offer several advantages over conventional freeway lanes and roads. 
They can:

·        Increase the average number of persons per motor vehicle using a highway over conventional lanes;

·        Preserve the person-moving capacity of a lane as demands for transportation capacity increase;

·        Enhance bus transit operations;

·        Support air quality goals;

·        Serve a variety of employment centers in urban and suburban areas; and

·        Provide predictable travel times even during periods of high demand for highway capacity.


Currently, HOV lanes exist in four Northern Virginia corridors: the 27-mile Shirley Highway (I-395
) I-95 corridor from Washington, DC to the south of the Beltway as far as Route 234 near Dumfries in Prince William County; the 27-mile I-66 corridor both inside and outside the Beltway from Rosslyn to Route 234 in Manassas; the 11-mile VA 267 (Dulles Toll Road), which has a concurrent-flow HOV lane between Route 28 near Dulles International Airport and the main toll plaza just west of Route 7; and Route 1 and VA 400 (Washington Street) through Old Town, Alexandria. These HOV lanes play a crucial role in the region’s transportation system. 

The success of Virginia’s HOV system is the result of substantial public and private investment in HOV lanes, park-and-ride lots, transit and car/vanpooling services, rideshare matching services, and popular “slug” opportunities—a form of casual carpooling.


Mode Share

As part of its core travel monitoring program, the National Capital Region Transportation Planning Board of the Metropolitan Washington Council of Governments (COG/TPB) conducts cordon studies that count the number of persons by travel mode. The last Metro Core Cordon Count was completed in 1999 while the latest Beltway Cordon count took place in 2001.  Figure 33 shows the counting stations for the Beltway and Metro Core Cordon study. Travel counts were conducted from 6:30 AM until 9:30 AM in order to capture the majority, but not all, commuter trips.


Figure 34 shows that when offered good HOV[8] infrastructure and transit service, less than half of all peak period commuters choose to drive alone.[9]  Figures 38 and 39 include the absolute numbers of commuters in the corridor as well the mode shares. The share of transit commuters increases closer to the urban core—a reflection of the greater degree of transit options.

Figure 34: 2001 Mode Share in the I-395 Corrador at the Beltway Cordon
6:30AM - 9:30AM

Another fact that emerges from examining the figures is the very strong shares of persons moving in the major commuting corridors via public transit.  The appropriate places and times to measure transit’s shares of commuting markets are during peak travel hours in corridors in which meaningful investments in transit services have been made.  As can be seen, public transit services in Northern Virginia capture very significant shares in these major corridors to the benefit of transit customers as well as to those that choose to drive alone (or with others) in automobiles.


Figure 38:  2001 Beltway Cordon Count Mode
Share
Summary for Major HOV Corridors
6:30 AM – 9:30 AM

 

SOV

HOV(2+)

Bus

Metrorail

VRE

I-395

 

 

 

 

 

Passengers

15900

17000

3500

0

0

%

44%

47%

10%

0%

0%

Route 1

 

 

 

 

 

Passengers

9000

2900

200

11000

2200

%

36%

11%

1%

43%

9%

I-66

 

 

 

 

 

Passengers

1900

7600

700

10600

1800

%

8%

34%

3%

47%

8%

VA 267

 

 

 

 

 

Passengers

6700

5800

3300

0

0

%

42%

37%

21%

0%

0%

Source:    1999 COG/TPB Metro Core Cordon Count, A.M. Peak Period.

 

Figure 39:  1999 Metro Core Cordon Count Mode Share
Summary for Major HOV Corridors
6:30 AM – 9:30 AM

 

SOV

HOV(2+)

Bus

Metrorail

VRE

I-395

 

 

 

 

 

Passengers

21300

21600

8200

0

0

%

42%

42%

16%

0%

0%

Route 1

 

 

 

 

 

Passengers

6800

3000

200

14100

1500

%

27%

12%

1%

55%

6%

I-66

 

 

 

 

 

Passengers

3300

13400

3700

23300

1300

%

7%

30%

8%

52%

3%

Source:    1999 COG/TPB Metro Core Cordon Count, A.M. Peak Period.

Travel Time Savings

   As shown in Figures 40 and 41 one of the notable benefits of using Northern Virginia’s HOV facilities is the substantial reduction in travel time over non-HOV travel. The HOV lanes usually move at speeds approaching the speed limit, while the parallel conventional lanes move at much slower speeds due to congestion. Survey data show that morning commuters using the HOV lanes shave about one half-hour off their commute on I-95/I-395 and I-66 and about 20 minutes off their commute on the Dulles Toll Road in comparison to commuters in the parallel conventional lanes[J1] .  Furthermore, commute time is more predictable in each of the corridors for those who choose the HOV lanes.[10]

    A 1999 study by the COG/TPB showed that during the afternoon peak commute the average speed in the HOV lanes on I-95/I-395 between the Virginia end of the 14th Street Bridge and Joplin Road (VA 619) in Prince William County, a distance of about 27.3 miles, reached 60 mph.  In the parallel conventional lanes, it took commuters 133% longer to travel the same distance at an average speed of 26 mph.  In other words, commuters using the HOV lanes saved 36.5 minutes or 1.34 minutes per mile during their afternoon commute. The study also shows significant travel time savings in the HOV lanes on I-66 and the Dulles Toll Road (VA 267).

    The Texas Transportation Institute estimates that the average auto commuter in the Washington DC metropolitan area suffers 84 hours of peak period delay annually due to congestion on the region’s freeways and major roadways.[11] Using a different methodology than the COG/TPB HOV performance study, the TTI calculates mobility levels for specific HOV corridors. [12] The results show even greater time savings for commuters using the HOV lanes. Commuters on a 55-mile section of I-95/I-395 save over one hour, commuters on a 34-mile section of I-66 save more than 30 minutes, and those who choose the HOV lanes on the Dulles Toll Road save nearly one-half hour. Clearly, commuters who take advantage of the region’s HOV lanes by traveling in vanpools, carpools or on transit can save many hours annually from their commutes.

Figure 40: Speed and Travel Time Comparison for HOV and Conventional Lanes
1999 Mean A.M. Peak Period

Corridor

HOV Lane Speed (mph)

Conventional Lane Speed (mph)

HOV Lane Travel Time (minutes)

Conventional Lane Travel Time (minutes)

Minutes Saved With HOV

Minutes Saved

Per Mile

I-95/I-395 (northbound)
From VA 234 (Dumfries) to VA end of 14th St. Bridge
27.6 miles

61

29

27

58

31

1.12

I-66 (eastbound)*
From VA 234 Business (Manassas) to VA end of T.Roosevelt Bridge
(27.5 miles)

40

25

41

69

28

1.02

VA 267/I-66 (eastbound)
From VA 28 to VA end of

 T. Roosevelt Bridge
25 miles

45

29

31

51

20

0.80

Source:       1999 Performance of Regional High-Occupancy Vehicle Facilities on Freeways in the Washington Region: An Analysis of Travel Times. Final Draft. National Capital Region Transportation Planning Board of the Metropolitan Washington Council of Governments (October  6, 2000).

 * HOV travel time savings is more reliable inside the Beltway than outside the Beltway. For the eastbound A.M. peak period, the standarD deviation of elapsed travel times in the HOV lanes is 1 minutes 46 seconds for the inside-the-Beltway portion of the run and 5 minutes 36 seconds for the outside-the-Beltway portion.

 

Figure 41:    Speed and Travel Time Comparison for HOV and Conventional Lanes
1999 Mean P.M. Peak Period

Corridor

HOV Lane Speed (mph)

Conventional Lane Speed (mph)

HOV Lane Travel Time (Minutes)

Conventional Lane Travel Time (Minutes)

Minutes Saved With HOV

Minutes Saved Per Mile

I-95/I-395 (southbound)
From VA end of 14th St. Bridge to VA 619
27.3 miles

60

26

27.5

64

36.5

1.34

I-66 (westbound) From VA end of T. Roosevelt Bridge to VA 234
27.4 miles

51

31

32

57

25

0.91

VA 267/I-66 (westbound) From VA end of T. Roosevelt Bridge to VA 28 
24.3 miles

54

43

27

36

9

0.37

 

Source:       1999 Performance of Regional High-Occupancy Vehicle Facilities on Freeways in the Washington Region: An Analysis of Travel Times. Final Draft. National Capital Region Transportation Planning Board of the Metropolitan Washington Council of Governments (October 6, 2000).

 


Person Carrying Capacity

As shown in Figure 42, more people can be moved per hour on an HOV lane than on a conventional lane.  HOV lanes on I-95/I-395 perform more efficiently than conventional SOV lanes because during peak hours, each HOV lane moves 3,800 persons per peak hour compared to the 2,200 persons per hour for each conventional lane. HOV lanes outperform conventional lanes every time, moving 1,600 more people per hour. The I-66 HOV lanes (outside the Beltway) move 900 more people than their conventional counterparts, while the HOV lanes on the Dulles Toll Road handle 600 more commuters than the parallel conventional lanes.

   Figure 42:  Person Carrying Capacity Comparison for 
   HOV and Conventional Lanes, FALL 1999

 

HOV Facility

Persons

Direction

Restricted Hours

A.M. HOV Lane Person Movement*

A.M. Conventional Lane Person Movement

A.M. Persons Pen HOV Lane, Per Hour*

A.M.      Persons Per Conventional Pane, Per Hour

I-395

North of Glebe Road

HOV-3

Northbound

 

6:00 A.M. - 9:00 A.M.

 

22,500

(2 LANES)

26,400

(4 LANES)

3,800

 

2,200

 

I-95

North of Newington

HOV-3

Northbound